top of page

When Technology Outpaces the Public: A Case Study on E-bikes

Writer: JCI Worldwide
JCI Worldwide
24 hours ago
5 min read

by Chloe Tachibana


Technology rarely waits for the public to catch up.


When cars first replaced horses in the early 1900s, cities faced a lack of infrastructure, regulation and understanding of new safety habits. The rise of the internet created a similar challenge: technology and adoption moved quickly, while policymakers and the public were still learning how to address issues like data privacy and digital footprints. Today, the same dynamic is playing out with emerging technologies, particularly artificial intelligence, as policymakers and decisionmakers work to understand their impacts and determine how best to respond.


E-bikes offer a more local and tangible case study of this same challenge: technology gaining widespread adoption before public understanding, infrastructure and policy have fully caught up. Their rapid growth across Southern California has forced communities to confront questions of safety, regulation, sustainability and public responsibility—questions that will only become more common as new technologies continue to reshape how we live.

E-bikes are complicated for a number of reasons. There are different classes of e-bikes with different capabilities and speeds. Many of the vehicles that the public complains about on city streets may not fall within one of the three legal e-bike classes and may instead be electric motorcycles or other types of vehicles. Many cities also do not have actual bike lane infrastructure, forcing cyclists to share the road with cars on busy streets. 


At the same time, California does not want to deter people from using these vehicles. E-bikes can be an important part of the solution for getting people out of cars and addressing climate change. They provide a zero-emission transportation option, save on gas and allow people to travel quickly uphill or over longer distances without the same physical output as a traditional bicycle.


The challenge isn't simply more people riding e-bikes. It's that technology, public understanding, infrastructure and regulation haven't always evolved at the same pace.

So how do we address the e-bike situation without discouraging innovation?

The answer requires a multifaceted approach, summarized by the three E's: Education, Engineering and Enforcement.


Education

The rise of e-bikes in Southern California has been largely spurred by children, many of whom are under the legal driving age and have not had proper road-use instruction.

School districts have been taking a lead in ensuring instruction on the rules of the road, particularly when students want the option of riding and parking their e-bike at school. For example, the Hermosa Beach City School District has partnered with the Hermosa Beach Police Department and E-Bike Sense on a district-wide e-bike safety program, which received the California School Boards Association's Golden Bell Award for youth safety education.


Efforts are also underway at the state level. AB 1569, signed into law after passing on August 27, requires the California Department of Education and the California Highway Patrol to develop e-bike safety training for students in grades 7 through 12. The program must be established on or before March 1, 2028, creating a statewide framework for educating young riders on safe e-bike operation.


Adequate education, however, has to happen earlier—with parents.


Many parents who buy an e-bike for their child do not have a clear understanding of how vastly different an e-bike can be from a regular bike in terms of power, speed and weight. To make sure children are safe and able to operate on roads already populated with cars, trucks, buses and pedestrians, parents need to understand the e-bike they are buying and make sure their child is equipped to ride it responsibly.


As Megan Lamb, founder of E-Bike Sense, explains:

“E-bike safety starts with education, and that includes parents. Our goal isn’t to keep kids off e-bikes. It’s to make sure every rider knows the rules of the road, how to ride defensively, and how to handle a faster, heavier bike in traffic.”


Education is the first step, but it cannot solve the entire problem.


Engineering

When new technology changes how people move through a community, infrastructure has to catch up. E-bikes are now sharing roads, bike lanes, sidewalks and intersections with traditional bicycles, pedestrians, cars and other vehicles.


That creates new questions for cities: Are bike lanes designed for the speeds of today's riders? Are intersections safe for multiple types of users? Is there adequate signage? Are there designated places to park e-bikes without creating additional pedestrian hazards?

Engineering does not mean building an entirely new system overnight. It means looking at how people are actually using streets and public spaces and identifying where infrastructure can make those interactions safer.


The goal should be simple: design communities around how people actually move, while making the safe choice the easy choice.


Enforcement

Rules only work when people understand them and when there are clear consequences for breaking them.


California has established different classifications and requirements for e-bikes, but the challenge for local communities is making those rules understandable and enforceable. Parents need to know what they are purchasing, retailers need to understand what they are selling, and riders need to know where and how they can legally operate. Law enforcement also needs the tools and training to distinguish between legal e-bikes and vehicles that fall outside the statutory definition.


SB 1167, passed this year and taking effect January 1, 2027, addresses part of this challenge by prohibiting high-powered electric motorcycles from being sold as e-bikes and requiring clear labels identifying an e-bike’s class and maximum speed.


Enforcement should also be paired with education and community engagement. In the South bay beach cities, E-bike Sense works with Beach Cities Health District on a youth diversion program that allows riders who receive citations can complete a safety course instead. The goal is not simply to issue citations. It is to create a culture where riders, parents and businesses understand the rules and why they exist. This approach turns a potential penalty into an opportunity to learn.


What E-Bikes Can Teach Us About Public Policy

E-bikes are ultimately about more than bicycles. They are a case study in a larger public-policy challenge: what happens when technology becomes widely adopted before the public, infrastructure and laws have had time to catch up?

The answer cannot be to simply stop innovation. Nor can it be to wait until problems emerge and then react.


Policymakers, businesses, schools, law enforcement and community members all have a role to play in adapting to new technologies. Effective policy requires listening to the people experiencing the benefits and challenges firsthand, understanding how the technology is actually being used and creating rules that can evolve as the technology evolves.


That balance will become increasingly important as new technologies enter our daily lives—from artificial intelligence and autonomous vehicles to clean-energy technologies and new forms of transportation.


The lesson from e-bikes is not that technology is the problem. It is that technology, public behavior and public policy have to evolve together.



When technology outpaces the public, the role of policymakers is to help close that gap through education, thoughtful infrastructure and clear, enforceable rules—so communities can benefit from innovation while keeping people safe.



Sources: 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page